I fully expect that string theory will eventually turn out to be completely unrelated to physical reality, but give rise to a new family of useful encryption algorithms or something. Research is like that.
https://mastodon.social/@gutenberg_org/113097055499105571
In _A Mathematician’s Apology_, G. H. Hardy argues for the virtue of mathematics as a beautiful aesthetic pursuit with intrinsic value that is not dependent on any kind of applied utility. He talks about various fields that in his view will •never• have any sort of practical application, and the two examples he gives are…number theory and relativity.
Oops!
Ah, I see some Wikipedia editor noticed the same thing — and I’m slightly misremembering what Hardy said (though the “oops” still applies!).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Mathematician%27s_Apology#Critiques
Number theory and relativity are great examples not just of how theories find surprising applications, but how ethically decoupled the applications are from the theory.
Number theory gave us encryption, but also blockchain.
Relativity gave us accurate GPS, but also nuclear weapons.
You just can’t know. Simultaneously hopeful and grim news for the theoretician who wonders whether their abstruse work might have tangible, practical value! Hardy’s “focus on the beauty” stance may be the wise one.
@inthehands fwiw, they largely developed GPS to get nuclear weapons on target.
really great video on Polaris and the technical challenges needed to make it happen back in the late 50s: https://youtu.be/dSih6Ch0Hzs
@thedansimonson
I did not know this story!
@inthehands I didn't either until like 3 days ago
@thedansimonson @inthehands "Computer through the hatch"
That was really a thing... with rounded corners! The sub's nav system was called NNSS, the Navy Navigation Satellite System (or "Transit"), described in the video. GPS came later. And yes, one of those Transit satellites was still off-and-on transmitting a carrier wave until a few years ago...
https://users.aalto.fi/~mvermeer/isbn9789526088723.pdf#chapter.12
@thedansimonson @inthehands BTW Transit 5B-5 is still going strong! Reception just a week ago