lingo.lol is one of the many independent Mastodon servers you can use to participate in the fediverse.
A place for linguists, philologists, and other lovers of languages.

Server stats:

53
active users

#hps

0 posts0 participants0 posts today

A history student wants to read “guns, germs and steel” to fulfill a reading requirement in my intro to biology for
#hps
course. I want to suggest a *better* book that might appeal to her. Which book should I recommend?

Replied in thread

@glynmoody
I find the separation of the ideal of "science" away from the actions of human scientists to be flawed.

Science is a human-community knowledge-creation project.
It can not exist separate from humans.

That separation would allow obviously poisonous statements like, "Science has never harmed anyone", "Science is free of bigotry", "Science is above human ethics".

cf "No one has ever been injured doing yoga." & #Eugenics

"the 2023 Conference of the Australasian Association for the History, Philosophy and Social Studies of Science (AAHPSSS) will take place at the University of Sydney, Wednesday 29 November and Friday 1 December, 2023.
The call for papers is now open!"
aahpsss.net.au/cfp-aahpsss-202 #hps #philosophy #philsci

AAHPSSSCFP: AAHPSSS 2023 ConferenceWe are pleased to announce that the 2023 Conference of the Australasian Association for the History, Philosophy and Social Studies of Science (AAHPSSS) will take place at the University of Sydney, …

#Oppenheimer #Bohm
#Science rolls on in a great variety of ways.

The doco below has it that Oppenheimer basically organized his theoretical physicist fellows to ignore work by David Bohm, even though they could find no refutation it.

And nuclear physics rolled on.

#STS Science Technology Studies #HPS History and Philosophy of Science.
#CopenhagenInterpretation #DeBroglieBohmTheory

Caution: Doco contains some music and explicit psychologizing.

youtu.be/cysMpadecfU

Replied in thread

@timnitGebru

"some witnesses to an alleged incident of fraud during Tessier-Lavigne’s time at the biotechnology company Genentech refused to cooperate because investigators would not guarantee them anonymity,"

A interesting approach by #MarkFilip.

Did that approach allow the following conclusion?

"There was no evidence that Tessier-Lavigne himself manipulated data in the papers reviewed, the report concluded ... "

I just saw someone use the word “sciencephobic” as pushback about being labelled transphobic because, according to them, XX=female XY=male is just “basic #science

So, you may not know this… but I spent quite a lot of time studying History and Philosophy of Science at Uni.

So I have spent a lot of time thinking and learning and writing and studying the question “so like… what even IS science??”

And it turns out that… wow that is actually a fucking difficult question to answer as it turns out?

So there are lots of ways that people try to define science but most of them fail pretty hard to describe the way science actually works in the real world. Which is why #HPS is so fun for me.

But anyway. It’s way more complicated than you’d think.

But one thing that I am sure about about science, is that science does some pretty intense and important sciencing when “we think we know how this works” doesn’t match up with “what actually happens”

t’s not ~basic science~ to say “well XY is male and XX is female”.

It’s ~basic science~ when you look at more closely at the world and discover “actually… wow, it’s WAY more complicated than that”

(Which, I must point out, biologists actually do. As it turns out, teachers don’t actually go into the full, wild, wonderfully baffling complexity of all human knowledge in High School.)